Penn State’s Jewish Studies Program Faces Questions After Hosting Holocaust Museum Critic

Executive Summary

On November 17, 2026, the Jewish Studies Program at Penn State University hosted Professor Erica Lehrer of Concordia University for a guest lecture entitled “Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?” The first sentence of the lecture’s description claims that “a central issue animating and transforming the museum sector is the call to decolonize.”

While much of the online criticism focused on the attack on Holocaust museums (a major communal priority of most large Jewish communities in the United States), a further look at Prof. Lehrer’s record calls in to question why someone with her radical views on Israel, Gaza, and antisemitism would be invited to speak by a Jewish Studies program in the first place.


ANTI-JEWISH VIEWS

Academics for Peace, October 2023 Letter

One week after the Hamas atrocities of October 7, 2023, a fringe leftist group called Academics for Peace released a letter. After decrying the murder and kidnapping of Israeli civilians (it’s noteworthy that they neglected to mention Hamas’s use of sexual violence) and paying lip-service to Israel’s right to defend herself, the letter makes demands of Israel – and only Israel – including to end the “occupation” and “Apartheid.” Israel was still counting and burying her dead and trying to figure out which civilians had been stolen away into Gaza and Professor Lehrer was already using the word “genocide” and calling on Israel to end “occupation” and “apartheid.”

Academics for Peace, December 2023 Letter

In December of the same year, Prof. Lehrer signed another Academics for Peace letter calling on the Biden Administration to force Israel to negotiate a ceasefire. The letter conflated Israeli hostages – kidnapped civilians – with Palestinians in Israeli prison for terrorism. The letter goes on to falsely accuse Israel of killing 15,000 civilians, “mostly women and children.” Those numbers aren’t even supported by Hamas’s own claims. The letter claims Gazans are starving despite the fact that no such starvation was or has been reported. The letter accuses Israel of subjecting Palestinians to apartheid. And, in an interesting turn of events for a group of academics, the letter claims Israel is flouting “binding UN Security Council resolutions” while linking to a page listing multiple resolutions almost none of which are binding under the UN system.

Jewish Faculty Against the IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism, Spring 2021 Statement

The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of antisemitism is the gold-standard to define contemporary Jew-hatred. It is used by governments and major organizations all over the world. Professor Lehrer, in 2021, joined a group of Canadian faculty in opposing the adoption of the definition. The letter claims:

  • That the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement is legitimate protest and not antisemitic.
  • The IHRA’s definition “essentialize(s) Jewish identity, culture, and theology.”
  • The IHRA’s definition “equates Jewishness and Judaism with the State of Israel – effectively erasing generations of debate within Jewish communities.”
  • The IHRA’s definition “distracts from experiences of anti-Jewish racism, and threatens to silence legitimate criticism of Israel’s grave violations of international law and denial of Palestinian human and political rights.” 

PENN STATE JEWISH STUDIES

According to Hillel International, Penn State has around 4000 Jewish undergraduates, the ninth-largest Jewish student population among public universities in the United States. The Jewish Studies program, in particular, has a duty to its students, its private donors, the University community, the Jewish community of Pennsylvania, and the taxpayers of Pennsylvania (who fund Penn State to the tune of some $240 million annually) to, at a bare minimum, promote truth and protect the Jewish students under their care.


CONCLUSION

With the extraordinary rise in hostility to Israel and Jewish students on American campuses, Jewish Studies departments should provide a bulwark against the smears of the antisemitic fringe left. Prof. Erica Lehrer – even days after October 7th of 2023 – is a devoted promoter of those smears. As laughable as Prof. Lehrer’s wish to “decolonize” Holocaust museums is, bringing someone with her history of aligning herself with some of the worst antisemites in academia is unconscionable. 


Follow Defending Ed

Follow Defending Ed on social media for real-time news, breaking investigative updates, and daily insights from the ground.